Secret Crushes

Dear Journal,

We were having a Tower sleepover the other night when Maeve brought up the one subject that always makes me feel tingly all the way down to my toes: Nick Montoya—aka, my super-secret sorta crush. I know I must have turned 50 different shades of red. I mean, it can be fun to talk about Nick with the BSG, but it can also be SOOOO embarrassing! And you won’t believe what Maeve was saying. She actually thinks I should…get ready for this…ASK HIM OUT!

Of course my first reaction was no no no no NO! No way am I ready for that. And then, when I thought about it some more, my reaction was still NO. Hanging out with Nick is so much fun, and I definitely don’t want things to get weird. We always have an awesome time just kicking a soccer ball around or even working on a school project together! I’m afraid that if I bring up the whole ‘I like you’ issue, things will get messed up.

And you know what? I’m totally OK with feeling like that. I think it’s cool that Maeve would be brave enough to just walk up to her crush and ask him out, but that’s sooo not me. I just want to take it slow and see what happens naturally. For now, the only crush I want to hear about is the one between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth from Pride and Prejudice!

Meanwhile, Club BSG members can also share their opinions about dating, crushes, kisses and stuff on our NEW survey ! Check it out -- tell us what you think!

you tell us ...

Do you think it's OK for me to keep a secret crush secret?

Your friend,

Email this page to a friend

Comments (1678)

stargodess11 writes:

	tell him

the comment above? VOTE!

+62

stargodess11 writes:

	you need to tell him maybe he will like you to. when i like a boy i tell him and he always likes me to. so tell him

the comment above? VOTE!

+51

balletbabe9 writes:

	i think it's totally fine to not tell your crush u like him or not ask him out, i mean that's the whole SECRET part of secret crush. good luck with nick.

the comment above? VOTE!

+77

legendarydefense writes:

	I think you should go ahead and tell him, he seems great 4 u! you would show confidence and set up other girls for the same thing! You would know what it feels like to! LD!

the comment above? VOTE!

+29

koko985 writes:

	I really like this guy but I won't tell anyone

the comment above? VOTE!

+25

matie writes:

	Charlotte, believe me don't tell him your'e just gonna break your friendship.Believe me i have a secret crush too it is

the comment above? VOTE!

+29

allamericangirl13 writes:

	kind of but it will get out aventually so might as well tell people

the comment above? VOTE!

+10

daijanae writes:

	GIRL, I LIKE A BOY BUT JUST CAN'T TELL HIM BUT HE TOLD ME HE LIKED ME BUT HE LEFT AFTER HE TOLD ME REAL QUICK.PS.IT'S OK TO HAVE A SECRET CRUSH YOU DONT HAVE TO TELL HIM YOU CAN WAIT FOR A WHILE TILL YOU FELL LIKE YOU ARE GOING TO BE ACUALLY READY TO TELL HIM.

the comment above? VOTE!

+28

sharly writes:

	I HAVE A SECRET AM ONLY TELLING YOU GIRLS DON'T TELL ANYONE ELSE, I LOVE Y**.

the comment above? VOTE!

+13

sharly writes:

Charlotte, plz don't tell him. i actually need an advice from the bsg, i actually like a guy, who is my friend's brother. i did,nt tell my friend neither did i tell him even though i notice he likes me too. fortunately i sent a sms to my friend about him when he was calling a girl and he called and i told him it was what i saw, he was somehow hurt but he said he would come to my house on Sunday i would be expecting him am very happy. We attend the same Church. and we have got talking, plz tell me was i right or wrong.COS I really do love him his name is Y**, he is more precious than Gold to me.

FROM YOUR FRIEND
SHARLY.

the comment above? VOTE!

+28

hockey07 writes:

	honestly Charlotte if Maeve, Katani, Avery and Isabel are ur friends u should be able 2 tell them. True friends would never make fun of u for liking Nick. I sure wouldn't

the comment above? VOTE!

+29

crazymonkey writes:

	I have never had a crush. My younger sister has her first Crush it's soooo CUTE! -crazymonkey-

the comment above? VOTE!

stellabear22 writes:

	Yeah. A secrets a secret. If you want some thing to remain private then keep it private. You can occasionally talk about it. But if you see things are heating up tell him how you feel about him. Chances are he likes you too. Or if you see a definite chance in a change in your location tell him. It might be your last chance!!

the comment above? VOTE!

+19

Maevegirl123 writes:

	no. my boy friend turned out to like me 2

the comment above? VOTE!

+16

dogszoo2 writes:

	I have had a huge crush on a boy named K*** and i have kept it a secret! im not sure if i should ask him out. Click the heart if you think i should ask him out!!!!

the comment above? VOTE!

+93

IAMHORSES writes:

	Well it really depends on if you feel confident enough, but, mark my words Char, I'm pretty sure he likes you. I you don't feel comfortable wait for him to make the 1st move. But remember, you are only in 7th grade. So if he doesn't, well, don't take it the wrong way because you Are a great person Best wishes, IAMHORSES

the comment above? VOTE!

+25

PointeShoe101 writes:

	I like this guy. We went to kindergarten together. But he goes to a different school. Boo-hoo! xoxo Pointe

the comment above? VOTE!

+10

Maeve30 writes:

Yah, that's perfectly fine and by telling everything changes between you and your risking your friendship. I think you shuld wit for him to make the first move if their is one. Just hang out, and build a tight friendship. Help each other out and prove to the world guys and girls can just be friends instead of everyone wanting more. I wish people were all just friends and nothing else. Our world could have a lot less emabarassment and more love in a friendly kind way. Good Luck with all your troubles Charlotte. I belive you can do it the right way!

the comment above? VOTE!

+18

hsmrocks writes:

	i think u should go out with him cause i think he likes u back i'm not ones to talk about boys cause i think boys should ask girls out maybe u should leave hints our just go up to him and ask him out whatever you think is better

the comment above? VOTE!

+11

katani_rulez_girl_123 writes:

	Don't tell! I like a guy in my class, and i told someone i like him, and gossip went flying around that i wanted to go out with him and it got to HIM. now he doesn't now how to act around me and people always tease me. Def don't!

the comment above? VOTE!

+13

bsglover28 writes:

	I think you should just hang out with him. If you want to go out with him, just DO IT!!!!! But only when your ready!

the comment above? VOTE!

+14

alexandriapegram writes:

	No I thank you should tell nick that you like him and maybe he might feel the same way.

the comment above? VOTE!

dramaqueen4everlife101 writes:

	don't tell him! things will just get weird. plus i think he mite like u back. and ur a poetic person, so u know that obviously the guy making the move is much more romantic. just see wat happens!

the comment above? VOTE!

ilovejesus writes:

	I think it's alright but don't keep it locked away forever you should maybe tell the BSG they probably know how you feel!

the comment above? VOTE!

saddlegaltex writes:

	Totally keep it a secret.I like this guy in my class and he has NO clue.Act like you don't like him.The guy won't care.

the comment above? VOTE!

kmak writes:

If it were me i would not tell him. I had a crush on this guy and still do but i don't tell anyone. I just act normal and be me. This guy he's so funny many time i end up sitting or standing , or doing any thing next to him. Yeah so there's this girl she told everyone that she liked my crush and now he's afraid to be next to her because she's annoying and her jokes AREN'T funny.
So anyway you get the point DON'T TELL him, maybe he might suspect you were doing stuff with him for another puporse but you weren't.
xo,
kmak

the comment above? VOTE!

purplegal writes:

	do whatever u want, i have a crush no one suspects i like him i told one of my frenz and two fam members i like him though

the comment above? VOTE!

ColorfulDiva08 writes:

	Of course you should keep it secret until you know how he feels about you!

the comment above? VOTE!

averysfan26 writes:

	hey charlotte. I think it's ok for u to keep ur crush a secret. of course, u should tell the rest of the BSG because they're ur best friends. i do that all the time because of a boy i really, really like now.

the comment above? VOTE!

thinkpink16 writes:

	Hey Girls! let me tell you something I kept my secret that I liked this guy my whole entire school year of 2007-2008 and I finally told him the day after the last day of school. He said Ok and walked away!!! So I never really found out if he actually liked me or if he never liked me through the school year. What should I do now???HELP!!!!! ThinkPink16♥

the comment above? VOTE!

babyv221813 writes:

	yes until u no his feelings 4 u

the comment above? VOTE!

kk51298 writes:

	i bet he's very cute!!!!!!!!!!

the comment above? VOTE!

JIMJOE writes:

	i always try 2 keep it secret but usully the entire middle skool will know no matter how hard i try

the comment above? VOTE!

missy1718 writes:

I have a very secret crush. Only a couple friends know. The thing is one of my very good friends is already kinda dating him, but they hardly hang out together! He knows me and we used to hang out a lot but now we're in totally different classes and he only talks to me from time to time. Keeping a secret crush can give you a very hard time. I think it's better not to have one but in my case I'd better keep it a secret. smilies/sad.gif

the comment above? VOTE!

lexy73 writes:

	when i c him my eyes sparkle.i dont now if he likes me

the comment above? VOTE!

volleyballer09 writes:

	well of course every girl has a secert crush! but yes i do know a MQT! haha. lol. ttyl evry1! luv volleyballer09

the comment above? VOTE!

BSGurl 516 writes:

	no because dont you want him to know about your feelings. and if you dont tell him in time he might be with someone else and then you'll feel crushed. so i think charlotte should tell nick. hey you guys should see the movie i made on the movie maker , it's called charlotte and nick's first date. it's really short, but it's coool

the comment above? VOTE!

Basketballgrl56 writes:

	i'm way 2 chicken 2 admit the truth i askefdf mi brother 2 ask him out 4 me 'cause i'm 2 scared! he's a MQT! (Mega cutie) (duh) whenever i c him, his eyes sparlke in mi eyes! THAT IS HOW CUTE HE IS!

the comment above? VOTE!

babby902 writes:

	ya because for me if i tell them i chicken out unless i dont realy like him that much but that is just me if u want him 2 know then tell him which ever ur comfertable with

the comment above? VOTE!

jbean12 writes:

	no tell them about it

the comment above? VOTE!

jacy1201 writes:

	let it all out but secretly....wh3n no 1 is there!most important... n3v3r s@y n3v3r

the comment above? VOTE!

jacy1201 writes:

	l3t ur fEelInGs 0Ut 2 d@ W0RLD @SK F0R S0M3 M@J0R H3LP....0R D0 it Urs3lf i m3an i @lw@ys d0 th@t...

the comment above? VOTE!

bostongirl writes:

	I think you should let ur crush know how u feel not keep it a ckret. Let ur feelings out. ttyl.

the comment above? VOTE!

cooliocutie21 writes:

	yes because people who like that boy too will embarass you in front of him and he will like the other girl better.....

the comment above? VOTE!

Martys_pal writes:

	Char, You should sit with him and slowly ask him how he feels. He will say he likes you and you already know you like him. He will probably ask you out, say yes, and then, tell him yes, but also tell him, whatever happens you will stay friends. If you agree, click the heart!

the comment above? VOTE!

+16

jennifur writes:

	You should ask him out because because jolie or anna will take him away from you. If you do ask him out can you tell us what book it will be in?

the comment above? VOTE!

bgirl82 writes:

	u shouldn't keep it a ckret bcause you don't want 2. and wen u do get the courage 2 ask him it mite b 2 L8. tell him and c wut happens. its okay tat happened 2 my frend she wuz a little L8 but he dumped his g-f for her. soooo do it tell him. don't worry were all here 4 u.

the comment above? VOTE!

AngelLove2134 writes:

	u shoudn't keep a ckret bcause it'll get botlled up inside.He likes u, and u DOOO! So do it.

the comment above? VOTE!

Lunatuna writes:

	Please, please, ask Nick out in Time's Up, or else I will scream. (If you don't Joline will.)

the comment above? VOTE!

dramaqueen407 writes:

	CHARLOTTE, IF I WERE YOU I WOULD TOTALLY KEEP IT A SECRET BECAUSE IF YOU BLURT IT OUT MAYBE THE PERSON WOULD START A RUMOR AND NICK WOULD KNOW! ITS LIKE 2 OF MY FRIENDS OR MORE KNOWS MY CRUSH AND I TOLD THEM TO NOT TELL, SO THE NEXT DAY I SAW MY FRIENDS TALKING TO MY CRUSH YOU KNOW FLIRTING I RAN AND TACKLE THEM DOWN BUT THEN I SLIP AND RAN INTO MY CRUSH! WE BOTH ENDED UP IN THE NURSES OFFICE!

the comment above? VOTE!

+11

writer101 writes:

	Charlotte, If you really like him th much left him come to you or talk to him some more and find out what he likes and write it down so when he asks you a question or is talking about what you like you will know and then he will see that you are listening to him and he will like a lot more and maybe you too could even go out!

the comment above? VOTE!

iluv_BSG writes:

	Char- it think its ok because its totally normal, and i bet he likes you back but if he dosen't then dont be stressed out you still be friends, besides it will be HIS loss.

the comment above? VOTE!

rcdoodles911 writes:

	i feel like i cant trust anyone with who i like anymore! everyone is always asking me who i like but then they all go and blab it to the school! what should i do?!

the comment above? VOTE!

livi writes:

	i dont think u should...yet it didnt work out well for me do some investigating first

the comment above? VOTE!

mimzey4 writes:

	I like my best friend who is a guy. the only person I told was my friend M** only because I know she can keep a secret, but if you don't want anyone else knowing, then, don't tell anyone. That's the way to keep a secret, but when Nick moves, or you move, tell him that you like him, you'll feel sooooo much better! Love, your friend, Maddie

the comment above? VOTE!

kaiyle writes:

	Charlotte, Instead of asking Nick out, try having one of your friends if he likes you as much as you like him. You don't want to ask him and then have him tell you he doesn't like you like that. It could totally ruin your friendship and you already said that you don't want to risk that friendship. I hope you take my advice and that it works. -kaiyle 12 yrs old

the comment above? VOTE!

trollz813 writes:

	Yeah no duh i like this guys (i'm best friends with) but i like his best guy friend so i say I like my best guy friend now every ones asking me witch one I like so yea if u want keep it secret Char! - ur friend, Jenna !

the comment above? VOTE!

shushu writes:

	who cares if u tell or not tell cuz u know everything happens for a reason!!!

the comment above? VOTE!

pacsungirl writes:

	i dont think its ok 4 charlotte 2 keep a crush cuz wat if he likes her back? idk?

the comment above? VOTE!

Natasha_D writes:

	well to me no because all I did was have a friend tell my crush J** that I lyked him.

the comment above? VOTE!

casy writes:

	Char I couldent agree more with you just let it all fall natraly let God control it you dont whant to ruine your friendship

the comment above? VOTE!

funnyfrogs432 writes:

	Char~ I would tell him because if he says wahtever (which he probally won't) it would be his loss. If you can't tell him face to face write a note!

the comment above? VOTE!

swimdude44 writes:

	hey- now that school's out, I'm afraid for next year! even tho we're only going into 5th, lots of people in my grade either like someone or have a BF/GF... next year, if people start telling people they like each other, should I tell my crush? I think he likes me! but who knows?

the comment above? VOTE!

funnygirl1997 writes:

	okay do not spread about ur secert crush cause if u do say anything it's not a secert anymore right????????????????

the comment above? VOTE!

angelicamisz writes:

	yes becuase you dont now if you tell another friend and she spreads roomers and then the boy youlike will find out that your freinds and people that is not your freind will now about thisso if i were you i would never tell your even though you can trust them.

the comment above? VOTE!

id_rather_b_dancing writes:

	Hey Char!! He probably likes you too so i suggest tht you email him so you don't feel as awkward as you would in person and he has time to think about it. Its worked before with me so i think you should try! Hope this Helps!! Love, ~Id_rather_b_dancing~ (wouldn't u?)

the comment above? VOTE!

Rainbowblue writes:

	If you cannot tell him just right him a letter under anymous and say at the end p.s. you have to figure it out on your own

the comment above? VOTE!

RiahRules writes:

	Charlotte, I say go for it!! Nick is so totally into you too! Go for it! Shoot for the stars!! If things get weird and he says no it is so totally his loss. GO CHAR!!!! Sincerley, RiahRocks.

the comment above? VOTE!

+14

stephstar3 writes:

	i like someone and i told him and he said ewwww. does that mean he really dosent like me?

the comment above? VOTE!

readingrules writes:

i think you should keep it a secret. no one needs to know you like him other than the people you want to know. things like this happen to me all the time, like my friend just starting liking this guy but i've liked him since first grade and even though we tell each other almost anything i've never told them i like him and i'm not about to. some things they should know some things they should not. hope i'm helping you charlotte. but i need your guys help, do you think i'm doing the right thing in not telling them???? smilies/shocked.gif

the comment above? VOTE!

cag1127 writes:

	well....it's not really alright for you to keep it a secret from Nick because what if another girl grabs him? but i read before in a book that one of the 3 things hardest to say is "I love you" so i really won't know what to do if i were you ..... hang in there buddy!

the comment above? VOTE!

pupluver4life101 writes:

	Hey, Yeah, it's TOTALLY okay to have a secret crush -- I know that I have mine. So, maybe it's time to make it not so secret and just go ask him out!

the comment above? VOTE!

pupluver4life101 writes:

Hey Charlotte,
Ok, I have to admit that you and Nick would go together really well. Anyway, whats a good book without a little romance and dating. Honestly, people could start rumors about you, but you have to take the risk -- isn't that what life is about?????? So, just ask him out. Also, I'm sure you, like all girls, will be surprised by what the male mind thinks -- he might like you!!!!!!!
xoxo

the comment above? VOTE!

cooliocutie21 writes:

	yes because my friend backstabbed me about that. i tried to tell her not to tell anyone but she made a rumor that i liked someone i don't even like. people are mean in this world don't tell anyone

the comment above? VOTE!

Astronomeer writes:

	Dear Charlottle, I say to TOTALLY GO FOR IT!!!! You never know what might happen. ( I only have one crush, and it's still a secret!) Plus, I think Nick is into you. Just be yourself. Your Fan, Astronomeer

the comment above? VOTE!

jewelmae8 writes:

	Hi Charlotte!I definetely know how you feel.I have a crush on one of my friends!He knows alright.And when I see him at school,I start to blush!So Charlotte,I definetely think its best to keep a secret crush secret! Plus,I bet Nick likes you! TTYL, -jewelmae8-

the comment above? VOTE!

Love_art writes:

	i am tellin' u that u have to ask him out !dont worry ! if he says no ,that means it is his loss . u r the best ,so how cud anybody say no to u ? hehe

the comment above? VOTE!

poohbear96 writes:

Hey Charlotte! i have some advice for you if you really like a boy then show it and maybe even become friends with him and if your already friends then get a little closer if he never knows that you like him then you may not get the chance to go out with him and to me him knowing is better then holding it because if he knows then theres a chance that he might like you back and dont be afraid to get rejected i mean if he doesnt want to go out with you then hes crazy if he rejects you he might have lost the girl for him so rejected or not you dont need a man all you really need is friends smilies/wink.gif

the comment above? VOTE!

MyEverydayLuvisRF writes:

Hi Charlotte! I know how you feel. I have a crush on my best friend! And it's really awkward at times. I don't really want to tell him I like him because I'm afraid I'll ruin our friendship - and I don't want that to happen! But if he ever shows signs of liking me... it wouldn't hurt to tell him how I feel. Nick likes you back so I can't wait to see if you two get together in a future book! You'd be a cute couple smilies/grin.gif

the comment above? VOTE!

+15

S.M.A.Rox writes:

	i totally think that it is ok for you to have a secret crush in mean, i have a ton lol!!!!!!!! your friend, S.M.A.Rox!!!

the comment above? VOTE!

SparkleGal writes:

	My crush found out, but it's OK. We're great friends, and we talk A LOT. But we're so busy flirting with each other, I forget what we talk about! I KNOW he likes me, but if I could only get it out of him . . . Anyway, it's not about me. Charlotte, A) Nick totally likes you! and B) Of COURSE it's OK to keep a crush a secret! It's part of the fun! SparkleGal

the comment above? VOTE!

llollipop writes:

	Ill have to admit I do like a boy i aid I didnt shhhhhhhhhhhh!

the comment above? VOTE!

xBSGxmarty writes:

char-
it's okay if you think you should keep it a secret. have maeve or avery or katani or isabel to ask him if he likes you. if yes, then just ask the hang together, and don't make it a "datey" thing. if you wanna go on a date, bring a group of friends. double/triple dates are always so fun. if you wanna keep it secret and wait for him, then do that! whatever you think is right is def best. hope this helps!

the comment above? VOTE!

melanee writes:

	it ok i keep my secret crush to my self to

the comment above? VOTE!

marck writes:

	when i was in 1st grade there was 12 boys that had a crush on me in 12 grade and i had a crush on all of them to and all of them had to stand in line at recess and i had to pick one boy and it was hard and so i pickt one and the next day he askt me out and my mom said yes and i went and hes my boyferend now

the comment above? VOTE!

hrl1729 writes:

	when i was in 4th grade a boy in 6th grade started calling me names and pushing me and then a boy in 5th grade came by and hit him and saved me

the comment above? VOTE!

hrl1729 writes:

	well it is and its not

the comment above? VOTE!

bobsgrandma writes:

OMG! Guess what happened on the last day 5th grade! So I was was walking to my locker with my binder. And a bully, ran into me and knocked me down. Then he started beating me up! Then a boy who's in sevnth grade punched the guy in the nose and saved me! Then he asked me if i was ok. I said yah and we talked! The next day he called and asked me on a date! I was only in fifth grade and my mom let me go! We went to the movies and he kissed me! It was so romantic!

the comment above? VOTE!

+16

bobsgrandma writes:

	Well its ok sometimes. I have this annoying girl in my grade and i toold her my crush. She told everyone in the grade and then i stopped liking him. And now my friends tease me!

the comment above? VOTE!

sk!nnyj3ans102 writes:

	Hi, Im kinda new to this and this is my first comment the thing i wanted to say is if yur like a boy or have a crush just go talk to him and be your self if your shy be shy if your funny then be funnt dont ack like someone else or any 1 just be yu....sk!nnyj3ans102

the comment above? VOTE!

chrstina1268 writes:

	Dear Ken. I SOOOO Agree with you

the comment above? VOTE!

ken writes:

	good for girls

the comment above? VOTE!

kariberry225 writes:

	Yes I do because I think it should be your desicion whether or not to ask the person you like out. I have a crush on someone, and the only people I know are my 3 bffs, but I would not want him to know it!

the comment above? VOTE!

Basketballgrl56 writes:

	Mgirl101, if u hate talking bout boy problems, then y r u even in this club? Click the heart if u agree w/ me!!! ~Basketballgrl56

the comment above? VOTE!

Basketballgrl56 writes:

	If a boy that u like signed ur shirt, u r concidered lucky! that happend 2 me on the last day ov 4th grade! i can also tell he likes me and my best friend gabby. i was askin her if she liked TJ, she said no and i asked her if she liked S** she addmidded that she does and i addmidded it 2, because if she addmidds something i addmided it 2!

the comment above? VOTE!

TuAnh writes:

	Tell him how u really feel........

the comment above? VOTE!

RosyPosy147 writes:

	go now! i promise that youll like it!

the comment above? VOTE!

RosyPosy147 writes:

	go to fashion and style page to read my post!

the comment above? VOTE!

Basketballgrl56 writes:

	Guys I was going 2 ask him out at the pool, but he was like hanging out with this other grl that he doesn't even know! i know her, but i was way 2 scared 2 tell her she was cheating on mi "future boyfriend" ~Basketballgrl56

the comment above? VOTE!

+11

Basketballgrl56 writes:

	wildcatchick101 just b urself and tell him u like him and u never no if he will like u if u think mi advice is good like the heart ~Basketballgrl56

the comment above? VOTE!

+31

Read More Comments >>
1 2 3 4 5 > Last ›